Supply and Demand? Malarkey I say.

If people are driving less and less and there has been no decrease in opportunity to get our hands on oil why are the oil companies saying that the day after day record high prices for gas is based off supply and demand?

Capitalism is unfortunately driven by greed (not that I know of a better system in which to have American businesses run). But since we’re already not run in a true market economy anyways would there be harm in America admitting that we’re a slightly mixed economy and have the government step in on products and services that effect the day to day lives and business of our beloved capitalistic society?

Though bitching about stuff is easy, coming up with solutions is not. So to try and offer at least a jumping point my thought would be this; If the oil companies are so big on justifying their prices by “supply and demand”, work with them to fix the price per barrel to a realistic supply/demand ratio and let the gas prices slide up and down as they will. While the idea is totally raw, it would accomplish a handful of things…

  • 1. Immediately drop the prices on a suffering economy
  • 2. Keep the oil companies healthy, profitable and strong
  • 3. Allow Americans to directly affect their cost of living

This would also still leave room to develop other sources of fuel and hopefully actually leave companies time to develop efficient fuel alternatives rather than using up half the worlds corn and continue driving up the price of food while making an inefficient fuel.

Bottom line, my thought on doing business in American Capitalism is to be able to have the freedom to make a good living and to also better the country and market (no mater how large or small of an effect you have) by how you run your company. Though that does add a whole “ethics” quality to the meaning of capitalism so maybe some people won’t like that.

Of course this idea opens up a whole other set of questions which I could address if this conversation gets any traction.

May 27th, 2008 | Life

5 comments

That 11 billion miles less was just from the month of March, which obviously translates to hundreds of billions of miles a year less if the trend continues.

That aside, I agree that advancements in technology and a glorified celebrity lifestyle has drastically increased people’s standard of living. Also, I do agree that the economy isn’t as bad as the media makes it out to be, but if you lined up the increase in people’s standard of living in the last 9 years with the increase in gas prices it won’t even compare.

The price of gas has more than quadrupled in the last 9 years ($.89/gallon the spring of ‘99 at the SA across from the Slater Estates). I won’t even begin with pointing at Bush for that because it’s not like we would have been better off had Gore or Kerry been in there, we’d just be paying the same for gas with higher taxes.

At the point where gas prices doubled or even was close to tripling you could write it off as a wave, just like the real estate boom that we’ve just been coming out of the past couple years, but with the supposed supply and demand based pricing so out of whack it’s about time we recognize it as an issue that is beyond out of control. I can make up for the extra $30 in gas a month by eating more ramen and totino’s pizzas but it’s not that easy for businesses or families.

Without any affordable and efficient alternative out there for people to buy into (save everyone getting a motorcycle or scooter) people and businesses are forced to rely on gas as a necessary thing to live life and do business.

Speaking of affordable alternatives, I hear that Honda is coming out with an affordable hybrid in 2009. So maybe 5 years from now when the general public can actually afford them we’ll see a decent alternative option actually be adopted by more than smug San Franciscoins (no offense to people from san fran, just a reference to a South Park episode on Hybrids).

Also, I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt that the “cut tivo and $5 cups of coffee” was pointed towards the common American and was not trying to make a dig at what you may assume to be my personal spending habits.

BTW, what’d you think of Indy 4?

Comment by The Colonel — May 28, 2008 @ 9:50 pm

I still trust in the market. Even with gas pushing $4 a gallon people are still-for the most part-willing to pay that price. Yes, people are cutting down on their driving (I just read today the U.S. drove 11 billion fewer miles in the last year than the year previous) but I honestly don’t think we’ve given the market enough time to adjust. Even so, I’m confident the market will create a new solution even if gas never becomes as cheap as it once was.

I also dismiss the doom and gloom surrounding the overall state of the economy. Yes certain staples we’re accustomed to have seen price increases (gas and food) but our standard of living is much higher than it was even 20 years ago. If you’re worried about the price of gas consider canceling the TiVo and cutting out the $5 cups of coffee. Markets go up and down and budgets need to adjust accordingly.

Comment by Chris D. — May 28, 2008 @ 8:39 pm

I agree that Government control usually does make things worse as they tend to take possible good ideas and ruin them with horrible execution. Since ethical free market capitalism is basically out of the picture I’m not sure how else we could try and maintain a healthy economy as it pertains to the market for natural resources without some kind of regulations or rules.

Comment by The Colonel — May 28, 2008 @ 11:22 am

I appreciate the points, and do agree that we have to admit that the current system is not (and less and less every day) a true capitalism. However, I think that the only way to have a sustainable system is to move back to supply-side economics and true free-market capitalism. Governmental control tends to not go so well, and I believe the current costs are largely associated with the current blocks on building refineries and drilling domestically thanks to the modern environmental movement.

Comment by Ryan D — May 27, 2008 @ 9:58 pm

Great looking blog BTW.
You raise a good point about capitalists, this market, contrary to what you hear about supply and demand is being fueled (so I believe) by a weak dollar. Which is the cost we have to pay for years of interest rate tinkering to keep the consumers spending and old fashioned speculation. Oil being the new gold, funds are flooding the market driving up oil futures. My sense, this is a classic bubble and it’s going to pop. I think the start of it was this weekend. The first time in 8 years that Memorial Day travel is down significantly. The ONLY good to come from this will be more interest in alt fuels and different transportation models. Then again, the current and future administrations are bought a paid for with corp money. They aren’t going to let this country move to a system that’s cost efficient. Remember what they did to the old street cars…

Comment by sank — May 27, 2008 @ 11:44 am